
Did Dispensationalists Coin the Term “Replacement Theology”?
Dispensationalists have often been accused of inventing the word “replacement theology” or “supersessionism” as a slur against covenantalists in an attempt to undercut their views on Israel & the Church—which they claim is the historic view of the church.
Based upon my research, A. Roy Eckardt seems to be the one who coined/popularized the term “supersessionism” in his article “Christian Perspectives on Israel” published in Midstream in 1972.
“The term supersessionism itself was coined in a 1972 article “Christian Perspectives on Israel,” by Protestant theologian and scholar of Jewish-Christian relations A. Roy Eckardt. The article was published in Midstream, an avowedly Zionist publication issued by the Theodore Herzl Foundation. Eckardt and his wife, Alice L. Eckhardt, were stalwart supporters of the Israeli government, and they blamed antisemitism for what they saw as Christians’ deficient support of Israel during the Six-Day War of 1967. In the years that followed, official rejections of replacement theology, by denominational leaders, were often accompanied by statements of support for Israel.”1
Continue reading “Replacement Theology Isn’t a Dispensational Myth”